Would You Read It #105 – The Superhero Rejects (MG) PLUS The August Pitch Pick!

Good Wednesday, Everyone!

First off, I have to apologize for not posting the winner of Friday’s book giveaway on Monday as I promised.  Monday’s post was all about Erik and his new book, and I didn’t want to steal any of his thunder. (Also, that post was WAY long enough already and I was afraid you might doze off and not fully appreciate the news :))

So, that being explained, I would like to announce the winner NOW.  Are you ready?

The winner (as randomly chosen by random.org) of Iza Trapani’s brand new, hot-off-the-presses, beautiful, fabulous Little Miss Muffet which shall be personally signed by Iza is:

Sue Heavenrich!!!!!

Congratulations, Sue!!!  Please email me so we can organize Iza signing and mailing you the book!  And thanks to everyone for reading about Iza’s wonderful book, bravely sharing your fears, writing some pretty amazing Muffet verses, and just generally joining in the fun!

Now, before we go any further, I realize many of you are fainting from lack of proper nutrition, so let’s get right to Something Chocolate, shall we?  There’s a nip in the air this morning, so I’m in the mood for a lovely mug of hot chocolate.  How does that sound?

Mmmmm!!!  Delish!  In case you were wondering, yes, there are mini marshmallows under the whipped cream 🙂

Now that you’re feeling fortified, let’s give someone a chance to have their pitch read by editor Erin Molta!  It’s time for the August Pitch Pick!

Our 4 wonderful pitches are:

#1 Darshana
Karina The Dancer (PB ages 4-8)

Free-spirited Karina wants to be a dancing star like her older sister. So she signs up for Indian classical dance, but her colorful attire, hip-shaking moves, and improvisations land her in hot water with Guruji, the teacher. Karina learns that to be a star, you just follow your heart, and do what you love.

#2 Lisa
The Golden Egg (PB ages 5-8)

The golden egg that doesn’t hatch creates quite a stir among the feathered friends on the farm. The Eggsperts are called and the Whisperers weigh in. In the end, Mother Hen must decide whether to follow their advice or listen to her heart.

#3 Carrie
The Cartwheel Queen (PB ages 3-6)

Overjoyed with her new-found ability to do a cartwheel, Queen Carina assumes the throne over her backyard kingdom of Cartwheelandia. Cheers and cartwheels explode through the crowd, but stop short with Carina’s heart-broken little brother. Carina makes it her mission to turn her brother’s “I can’t” into the confidence of a Cartwheel King.

#4 Alicia
The Savage Queen (YA)

Roma Whitewood is charged with treason for trying to protect the only family he has ever known as they are murdered before his eyes at the hands of the King’s Royal Army. The country Roma has always called his own, betrays him as his punishment is to be stripped of his citizenship and sent to work in the treacherous labor camps, where he meets Lyra and she opens his eyes to the truths of the world that he had been overlooking his whole life. All of the stories his mother told him as child, that he never even dared to believe, all begin to come true and Roma must face the ultimate decision: be oppressed or join the Uprising with Lyra. There’s more to Lyra than she’s telling him, but Roma can only put his trust in the hands of the girl who had been by his side every moment in the camps. She was going to escape, or die trying, and Roma was going with her, no matter the outcome.

Please choose the one you think is best and most deserving of a read by Erin and cast your vote in the poll below by Sunday September 22 at 5 PM EDT.

Thank you!!!

Today’s pitch comes to us from Wendi.  Wendi Silvano quit teaching in 1994, when her 3rd child was born. She has been writing for children ever since. She writes picture books, emergent and early readers, early chapter books and educational materials. Two of her picture books have won the Children’s Choice Award. She lives in Grand Junction, Colorado. You can visit her website at www.wendisilvano.com. This pitch is for her first MG book.

Working Title: The Superhero Rejects
Age/Genre: Early MG
The Pitch:  Morphus is ashamed that he doesn’t have a normal, exciting superhero skill. All he can do is morph into lame objects like paperclips, rubber bands and light bulbs. And it’s particularly embarrassing when you are the brother of one of the most infamous graduates of ZITS (The Zapdor Institute for the Training of Superheroes). He and the other Superhero Rejects are relegated to practice their pathetic skills in the old gym in the basement when the villainous Scorpius attacks the school and puts everyone into a hypnotic trance… everyone that is, except the Superhero Rejects. Can they save the school and prove they are “real” superheroes too?


So what do you think?  Would You Read It?  YES, MAYBE or NO?

If your answer is YES, please feel free to tell us what you particularly liked and why the pitch piqued your interest.  If your answer is MAYBE or NO, please feel free to tell us what you think could be better in the spirit of helping Wendi improve her pitch.  Helpful examples of possible alternate wordings are welcome.  (However, I must ask that comments be constructive and respectful.  I reserve the right not to publish comments that are mean because that is not what this is about.)
Please send YOUR pitches for the coming weeks!  For rules and where to submit, click on this link Would You Read It or on the Would You Read It tab in the bar above.  There are openings in November so polish up your pitches and send yours for your chance to be read by editor Erin Molta!

Wendi is looking forward to your thoughts on her pitch!  I am looking forward to sharing a very fun book with you on Friday for Perfect Picture Books and also announcing the winner of Erik’s very first published book, The Adventures Of Tomato And Pea, Book 1: A Bad Idea!  If you haven’t had a chance to read his interview and enter to win, there’s still time!  Hop on over HERE.

Have a wonderful Wednesday, everyone!  May the muse be with you 🙂

52 thoughts on “Would You Read It #105 – The Superhero Rejects (MG) PLUS The August Pitch Pick!

  1. Tonja Drecker says:

    Oh, that hot chocolate did wonders! Yummy.
    I already fell in love with Wendi's pitch in the first sentence – morphing into paper clips 🙂 The only thing that made me stumble was the part, where everyone is hypnotized except the rejects. I wondered why they weren't caught. After another read and a few seconds thought, I realized the evil guy must not have found them in the basement – maybe smooth this thought-bridge. But the rest is great!

  2. Iza Trapani says:

    Wendi's pitch is hilarious! It may be a little long, but it's so well written that I am not sure. I can't wait to read the book!
    Congratulations to Sue on winning my book! And now I am off to that post to read and reply to those comments, which I haven't had a moment to do until now…

  3. Teresa Robeson says:

    Congratulations to Sue! And mmmm hot chocolate. It's a tad nippy here this morning too.

    What a terrific lot of pitches to choose from! I voted.

    And Wendi's pitch, like Iza said, is a touch long but otherwise absolutely perfect! Go, Wendi!! 🙂

  4. Angela Brown says:

    Congrats to Sue for winning 🙂
    And I enjoyed today's pitch. It was clear and concise so I have not advice for improvement. For me, it reminds me a lot of a younger version of Sky High.

  5. Katie Cullinan says:

    I like Wendi's pitch too! I do think it's a tad long. While the acronym ZITS is cute, I got a little bogged down at the point where you spelled it out. Perhaps a few tweaks here and there would streamline it.

  6. Pam Brunskill says:

    Congratulations, Sue! I voted 🙂

    As for Wendi's pitch, the book sounds hilarious! Yes, I would read it. Based on other pitches I've read, it seems a bit long, but I really liked it! Maybe play with shortening these two sentences?

    And it’s particularly embarrassing when you are the brother of one of the most infamous graduates of ZITS (The Zapdor Institute for the Training of Superheroes). He and the other Superhero Rejects are relegated to practice their pathetic skills in the old gym in the basement when the villainous Scorpius attacks the school and puts everyone into a hypnotic trance… everyone that is, except the Superhero Rejects.

    Good luck!

  7. sue heavenrich says:

    yippee! a book from Iza – and to think I was gonna forsake the morning chocolate treat and just go do work!
    So – hard choices for the vote…. argh! they all sound good.
    As for the Superhero Rejects pitch – I love it! I would definitely read it. I love the ZITS school & love that there are a group of “rejects” – these are the folks I would bet my money on any day. Ages ago, when I coached youth soccer, I often created winning teams from the kids no one else wanted. You know, the “rejects”. So, yes, Wendi – I would read your pitch. heck, send the whole book!

  8. Kirsten Larson says:

    Congrats, Sue! Wendi, your book sounds fascinating. Not that I'm a pitch pro, but my understanding is you need two sentences max to show your character and the main conflict. So, I would suggest you chop, chop, chop away at your pitch. I'm going attempt to get it into two sentences here:
    “Morphus is ashamed that his superpower is turning into lame objects like paperclips, rubber bands and light bulbs. But when the villainous Scorpius attacks the school and puts everyone into a hypnotic trance, Morphus and his band of superhero rejects are the only ones who can save the school.” Or something like that, anyway. Good luck! (P.S. Love Grand Junction. One my best pals from high school lives there, and I've visited a few times.)

  9. Lauri Meyers says:

    First, I just ate a snickerdoodle for breakfast. Apparently, I've been reading your blog for too long!

    Great pitches to pick from!

    Yes, I would read it. Here's a suggested edit, though I think it's still a bit long:

    Morphus' only superhero skill is morphing into lame objects like paperclips, rubber bands and light bulbs. It’s particularly embarrassing when you're big brother is the famous
    INSERT NAME. At ZITS (The Zapdor Institute for the Training of Superheroes), he and the other Superhero Rejects are relegated to practice their pathetic skills in the old gym in the basement. When the villainous Scorpius puts all the students in a hypnotic trance, he forgets about the Superhero Rejects. Can they save the school and prove they are “real” superheroes too?

  10. Donna L Sadd says:

    Yep, I'd read it; it sounds like fun. I agree with the previous suggestions to cut and combine the first few sentences, to tighten the pitch.

  11. Julie says:

    Congrats!, Sue, now you
    need to write a review.
    Add to, do, few,
    who, cue, NA!
    You didn't think I was gonna keep going,
    did you?

    Voted – good luck, all!

    Hi Wendi! The pitch needs tightening for me, but I would definitely pick it up! Here's a chopping block attempt:

    All Morphus can do is morph into lame objects: paperclips, rubber bands, light bulbs – UGH! And it’s particularly embarrassing that his brother is an infamous graduate of ZITS (The Zapdor Institute for the Training of Superheroes). But when the villainous (try something more unique – nefarious?) Scorpius attacks the school, Morphus and the Superhero Rejects may just prove they are “real” superheroes too!

  12. Rosi says:

    I wasn't too sure about this one until I got to the part about the only hope being the Superhero Rejects. That is a fun premise and one a lot of people would enjoy. The pitch should be trimmed and tightened, but yes, I would read this one.

  13. Beth Arnstein says:

    Wendi, this pitch is fantastic! I would read it. In fact, I can't wait! The only thing I would change is perhaps the part after you explain ZITS. That next sentence is a looong one. Does training in the basement save them from the hypnosis? Is there a way to include this information without quite so many words? Also, I'm not a big fan of ending with a question. As I said, though, I would (will:) ) read this book. Good work!

  14. Wendi Silvano says:

    Thanks so far, everyone, for your help. It's wonderful to have other writers to bounce this off of! You've all been helpful!

  15. Yvonne Mes says:

    I love the subject matter of your pitch Wendi. If I was a middle grader the pitch would certainly grab my attention, a group of reject superheros saving the world is a great concept. I am not sure about length for pitches on MG novels, but it seemed fine to me. Just maybe consider the mention of the brother in there, is it really necessary? And the way it reads now, the 'He' in the fourth sentence could be interpreted to be about the brother where I think you want to be focusing on the MC.
    But Yes, I would be reading it!

  16. This_Kid_Reviews_Books_Erik says:

    Yes, mostly because I love super-heroes and plots like this. I would love to read this book as a regular MG, not an early MG. Congrats Ms. Heavenrich!

  17. pennyklostermann says:

    Congratulations, Sue!!! Lucky you!
    I voted.
    I would definitely read Wendi's book based on the pitch. I do agree that you can tighten it and improve it. I don't have any new advice, Wendi. You've been given excellent advice in previous comments. This is such an appealing premise for a story!

  18. Cathy C. Hall says:

    Well, I don't think there's anything I can add to what's been said already–LOVE this premise and would definitely read more based on this pitch. But (come on, you knew there had to be a but) I wouldn't use “lame.” Maybe switch that out to “ordinary”? I know it's a common expression with kids and we all know what you mean, but it still feels a bit politically incorrect to me. Still, good stuff and good luck!

  19. Wendi Silvano says:

    Thanks to everyone once again… I have received only wonderful advice. And thanks to Susanna for hosting this process! You rock!

  20. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    You are very welcome, Wendi! I'm so glad if it's been helpful. We are lucky to have such a wonderful bunch of astute and generous readers here who are always willing to help and always have such insightful things to contribute! Thank you for being brave enough to pitch! (And I think your story sounds really engaging – I would read it! :))

    Settings

  21. Robyn Campbell says:

    I do have the darkest circles under my eyes. I just have to look at Faith's story. Then to bed I go! (I'll be off line next week for a time. I found out we have to stay Thursday instead of getting to come back home.) What will my horsies do with me???

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s