Would You Read It Wednesday #110 – Broccolilocks (PB)

Do you ever get ideas but have no idea how to make them a reality?

I am full of ideas… but when it comes to execution I lack many skills 🙂  Drawing, for example.  Doing anything at all with photoshop, for another.  Also, there are those who would say that dancing is not my forte (although I do it with a great deal of enthusiasm :))

So imagine my delight at having children who are just SO much more competent than I am!

As a result, I am finally going to have something I’ve been desperate for for about 7 years.

Bookplates!

My own beautiful bookplates!  (They are so pretty!  Wait until you see!)

They are designed, and I ordered one sheet so I can see how they look.  (Just in case there are any problems with the printing, I don’t want ten million not-quite-right ones :))

Due to the fact that the one sheet cost $3.99 and the cheapest possible shipping I could get was $5.04, I chose the cheapest possible shipping and now have to wait 14 days.

But what’s 14 days after the approximately 7 years I’ve already waited?

As soon as I have them, I’ll show you!

And then the really fun thing is that if you want a signed copy of one of my books but you live in Kamchatka or somewhere that is not right around the corner from me, you can simply purchase the book from your favorite bookseller, email me with who/how you want the book signed, and I can mail you a book plate just how you want it and you can stick it right in!

Voila!  An idea has become reality!

That is just so exciting that I think we need a snack!  I have a total craving for apple cider donuts, so

… help yourselves!  (I realize these are not technically Something Chocolate, but it’s only cider donut time for a short portion of each year and they really are best fresh :))

Now then.  Are you ready for today’s pitch?

It comes to us from Julie who has visited us twice before (WYRI #68 Eddie Brick Visits The Aunts and WYRI #75 Just Call Me The Kid.)  A scribbler of children’s stories in between chores, Julie Rowan-Zoch has visited three continents, attempted to learn 4 languages, and has a 2-3-3-3-3 phalangeal formula in both of her hands and feet. (Though not yet able to get a good grip with her toes, she has been drawing with her hands since she exchanged a banana for a crayon.)  Please come visit her on her blog and view her beautiful artwork!  (Really, it’s amazing!  You’re in for a treat so go see it!)

Here is her pitch:

Working Title: Broccolilocks
Age/Genre: Picture Book (ages 3-6)
The Pitch: CRUNCH! Broccolilocks has a GIANT appetite for her prized vegetable. MUNCH! But a mysterious stink leads her nose down the garden rows to find that something has been munching on her broccoli! 

So what do you think?  Would You Read It?  YES, MAYBE or NO?

If your answer is YES, please feel free to tell us what you particularly liked and why the pitch piqued your interest.  If your answer is MAYBE or NO, please feel free to tell us what you think could be better in the spirit of helping Julie improve her pitch.  Helpful examples of possible alternate wordings are welcome.  (However, I must ask that comments be constructive and respectful.  I reserve the right not to publish comments that are mean because that is not what this is about.)
Please send YOUR pitches for the coming weeks!  For rules and where to submit, click on this link Would You Read It or on the Would You Read It tab in the bar above.  There are openings in January so you’ve got a little time to polish up your pitches and send yours for your chance to be read by editor Erin Molta!

Julie is looking forward to your thoughts on her pitch!  I am looking forward to when my bookplates arrive!  Did I mention that I have 5 different ones?  So awesome! 🙂  I can’t wait to show them to you!

Have a wonderful Wednesday everyone!

106 thoughts on “Would You Read It Wednesday #110 – Broccolilocks (PB)

  1. iza trapani says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I too, have been meaning to make book plates for years… Can't wait to see yours!
    Now would you please explain Julie's strange phalanges?

    Of course I would read Broccolilocks! I love the title! It's not clear to me who is making the crunching sounds Broccolilocks or the stinky critter (skunk?) But I do love the sounds! Maybe she could just clarify that a bit. Also, I would take out the “But” after “Munch.” And then i'd add a final short sentence giving a hint to the plot. And, assuming this story is based on Goldilocks and the three bears, it might be fun and effective to add something like: “Who's been munching on my broccoli?” Hope this helps! I can't wait to read the story!

  2. Angela Brown says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Apple cider donuts. Now that is interesting. And I've wondered what book plates are for so that is something for me to check out.

    Yes, I would read today's pitched story. I am a little curious of the stakes for the PB but the way it is, with a little tweaking advised from the ever-wonderful Iza, really piques my interest.

  3. Tina Cho says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Congrats on your bookplates! Very cool! Mmm, those donuts look delicious!
    And Julie, yes, I'd read your book. Love the title! I like the pitch so far, but maybe u could add a little more to it to show what Broccolilocks is going to do about her problem.

  4. Pam Brunskill says:
    Unknown's avatar

    You basically said everything I was planning, Tina! Looking forward to seeing the bookplates, Susanna. Julie, I was going to suggest adding one more sentence to show how the story/Broccolilocs evolves. Good luck!

  5. Kirsti Call says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I've been looking into bookplates, Susanna. Where did you order them from?

    Yes, I would read this story! The title itself is intriguing and I love fractured fairy tales…very clever!

  6. Catherine Johnson says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Can't wait to see your bookplates, Susanna. I ought to show my book trailer soon it's really tongue in cheek ha ha ha haaa!
    I've read this cute story and this is a great pitch for it, Julie. I wonder if you need to hint at what happens next though without a rhetorical ?

  7. mike allegra says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I would read Broccolilocks, but I would suggest changing the title. I expected a story about someone who had vegetable hair.

  8. Joanna Marple says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Yay for bookplates.

    Julie: AWESOME voice in your pitch. It's a yes from me, with the same advice as the others to add one more sentence. I also found the name hard to say, and am not sure how easy this would be for a read-aloud?

  9. coleen patrick says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Yes, a cute and catchy pitch!
    Looking forward to seeing your bookplate. Exciting! And thanks so much for the apple cider donuts, because I've really been trying to eat more fruits and veggies! 🙂

  10. Donna L Sadd says:
    Unknown's avatar

    The bookplates sound like a very smart idea, Susanna. I hope they're FAB when you receive them!

    Sure, I'd read it, Julie, and agree with Tina and Pam on improving it just a bit.

  11. Julie Hedlund says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Congratulations on your bookplates! I covet them too!! I have to give the pitch a maybe because I felt the title set us up for a story about a girl who has or ends up with broccoli for hair. The pitch, however, seems more about a girl who solves a mystery. I THINK it's a twist on Goldilocks where something is eating the broccoli instead of porridge, but I need a little more clarity. I can already see your amazing illustrations for this story though!!! Keep at it!

  12. Juliana Lee says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Morning Susanna! Those donuts would go great with my coffee! I would definitely read BROCCOLILOCKS. I have a three-year old granddaughter who loves broccoli, it's not her favorite vegetable, it's her favorite food! I can just imagine her with broccoli locks and a little basket over her arm. I think the MUNCH and CRUNCH really add to the flavor of the pitch.

  13. Renee LaTulippe says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I read an early draft of this super-cute story and would read it again! I really like the poetry of the pitch, but think it needs one more sentence to give us another hint of the plot. I ditto what Iza said, basically.

    Nice work, Julie!

    And Susanna, yay for bookplates!

  14. Andrea says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I Iike the mystery of what's happened to the broccoli and love the crunchy language! The one thing I wonder is whether this story has some hidden message about eating your veggies, which would make think twice about it. But I do like the twist on Goldilocks.

  15. Wendi Silvano says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Now I want a donut too!
    I would read the story, but I do think the pitch needs to give a better clue about Broccolilocks. At first I thought she might be a giant, then I thought she might be just an oridinary child, so I am not certain how to picture her. I like the “CRUNCH and the MUNCH”.

  16. Rosi says:
    Unknown's avatar

    I love the humor in this pitch and also the mystery. Hmmm. Do skunks also love broccoli? I will just have to read this one to find out. Great pitch!

  17. Wendy Lawrence says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Yes! I would love to read it because I love all things broccoli. I did have a lot of questions though. Is the prized vegetable broccoli? If so, why does she have to go away from it to find the broccoli-eater? I think I just had a hard time visualizing what was going on. I loved the conciseness, but maybe a more robust setting/character set up? So I can see what's going on?

  18. Susanna Leonard Hill says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Thanks for your comments for Julie, Angela! And WHAT? Have you never had a cider donut? You are totally missing out and I insist you go find yourself one immediately! 🙂 As for book plates, they are simply stickers of whatever shape you like (rectangular, oval, what have you) that you can inscribe and then stick on the inside cover of a book. Pretty basic. Therefore pretty pathetic that it's taken me this long to get some organized 🙂

  19. Susanna Leonard Hill says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts for Julie, Kirsti! And I ordered the bookplates from Vista Print. I haven't found a site that had exactly what I want… partly why it's taken me all this time…! But Vista Print has 3×4 stickers that allow you to upload your own design. My clever daughter was able to design what I wanted on photoshop and we just uploaded it onto the sticker template. They're quite simple, because you need room to sign. But the design looked great to me 🙂

    Settings

  20. Susanna Leonard Hill says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Thanks so much for your helpful comments for Julie, Joanna! And I hope the bookplates will turn out as well as I hope they will! 🙂 I'm can't wait to have a moment to read the next installment of your teen travels! 🙂

  21. Susanna Leonard Hill says:
    Unknown's avatar

    Thanks for your vote of confidence for Julie, Coleen! And as for the donuts, you know, I care about you guys! Your health is important to me. So if I can in some small way help you get your fruits and veggies, then I feel like I've done a good thing 🙂 🙂

Leave a reply to Joanna Marple Cancel reply