Oh Susanna – How To Cope With Critique Group Feedback?

Happy Monday, Everyone!  It’s an Oh Susanna day!  But first, I’d like to give you a teensy report on the Reach Out And Read Event I did last week.

Reach Out And Read is a terrific program that seeks to put books in the homes and hands of children who would otherwise not own a book, and to educate their parents on the importance of reading to children.

We had a great crowd at the Ossining Open Door Clinic for the event.  So many eager listeners gathered on the rug to hear Can’t Sleep Without Sheep and Punxsutawney Phyllis.

Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira
Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira

Afterwards, many asked to have their books signed, and/or to have their photo taken with an actual author (and Phyllis and Baahb :))

Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira

All of them went home with books of their very own, thanks to donations from you and others.  We had so many books that families who brought 3 or 4 children were able to get a different book for every child and go home with several titles.

Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira
Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira
Photo by Ana-Maria Cabreira

It was truly a wonderful day.  Thanks so very much to all of you who donated books!

And now, today’s Oh Susanna question comes to us from Eric.  He says, “I love my writer’s critique group that meets each month.  They offer great feedback — LOTS of feedback.  But, I am often overwhelmed when I get home.  Do you have tips or tricks to managing feedback to use it effectively to improve your work?

This is an excellent question.

Whenever you hand over your beloved work – product of your blood sweat and tears – even though you know logically that it probably isn’t perfect, you secretly hope that your critique readers will come back with comments like, “This is the absolute best thing I ever read!  You’re a genius!  Submit it immediately!”

So when you get the logically expected feedback, your writerly defenses automatically go up.  No matter how mature and professional you are, you can’t help it.  Nor should you.  You worked hard on this!  You need a little time to let the comments sink in before you can fairly evaluate them.

So my advice is this:  don’t decide anything right away.  Part of that overwhelmed feeling is the natural result of having your hard work picked apart – it has more to do with emotion than technique.

So take all that feedback home.  And the next day, or the day after, take it out.  Read it over.  Think it over.  Let it simmer.

Then, when the writerly defenses have lowered their swords and you’re in a place where you can realistically evaluate the feedback, go through your ms one page at a time and see what you agree with and what you don’t.

I find it easiest to start with things that I agree with and/or are very easily fixable – like typos 🙂  This way you don’t have to start by making concessions in your work.  If you fix the easy things first, it’s a little less difficult to tackle the harder stuff.

You can also organize your critiquers’ comments into categories and approach your revision one topic at a time – overall plot, character development, dialogue, language use etc. – and make your revisions accordingly.

Were there things that ALL your critique members agreed on?  Those things should be tackled early on as they have the most likelihood of really being things that should be addressed.

Other things that were only mentioned by one person, you as author have to evaluate in terms of your story intent – does your critiquer have a valid point, or did they miss the point?  And if they missed the point, was that the fault of your writing and can you fix that?

Obviously, the longer the work, the more extensive and complicated the feedback may be – it’s going to be very different for a YA novel than for a picture book.  But the basic approach remains the same:  let it simmer, tackle the easy stuff first, then go through by page or category and tackle the harder stuff.  And if there are things you feel strongly should be left alone, well, you’re the author!

I hope that at least partially answers your question, Eric.  If you have follow-up questions, or more specifics, add them in the comments and we’ll all try to help.

And now, I hope some of our devoted readers who also deal with critique group feedback will chime in with their advice on how to handle it – how do you make the best use of your feedback, and how do you keep from feeling overwhelmed?

44 thoughts on “Oh Susanna – How To Cope With Critique Group Feedback?

  1. Joanna Marple says:

    What lovely, lovely photos of the Reach out and Read event, and what a worthwhile program. It looks like you all had a splendid time!

    I petty much do what you have suggested with critique. I have two critique groups and a critique partner, so I always find it amusing when I get completely contradictory advice…. such critique I often have to sit on quite a time before deciding what to do!

  2. Coleen Patrick says:

    What a great even Susanna! The photos are so sweet 🙂
    And as for critiques–I think letting it simmer is great advice. Then you can decide what to use, because you don't have to use it all!

  3. Robyn Campbell says:

    Look at all those sweet, sparkly faces. Yay you!!!!!!!!!

    You are right on with your answer, Sus. I do the same thing. The stuff I agree with I usually change right away though. The the rest I ponder. And let it percolate.

    Smooches. 🙂

  4. Penny Klostermann says:

    How exciting for children to have books. Their sweet little faces show such happiness.

    Good critique advice. I've been in my wonderful group a little over a year and am slowly learning all the things you talked about. I try to let it rest unless a revision is glaring and unemotional. I taught elementary Physical Education for years and one of the hardest things to get across was how important the delivery of the pass is! I would hear complaints about the one catching…”He/she didn't catch my pass. I threw it right to them.” so I try to think of it in those terms …. If they didn't catch it, there's usually a good reason. The basis of a good pass starts with delivery….same with the basis of a good story….delivery that will be caught by all readers. In our mind we are passing it along perfectly, but with several members in a critique group we get a true picture of how effective our delivery is. It really helps me to hear from all the published folks that they still have critique partners/groups. I used to think once you learned how to write one story that was worthy of being published that you had the skill….just write and submit and volià….published! Oh Susanna, thanks for this great post.

  5. Beth Stilborn says:

    I have just become involved in my first critique group, although I've had other critiques (the most valuable have been from a freelance editor). This is so helpful! Thank you, Susanna, and thanks to Eric for submitting the question.

  6. patientdreamer says:

    What a wonderful time those kids are having, you can tell by their faces..lol. Yay You!! Thankyou for the advice regarding critique groups. I don't belong to a group just yet, but this has been very helpful. Thankyou Susanna

  7. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    Aren't those kids the cutest? It made my week to be able to watch them trundle off home clutching their brand new books. I'm so grateful to everyone who donated and made that happen! And I'm glad if the critique group comments are helpful. In general, people seem to pretty much agree. I was kind of hoping someone would come up with something I hadn't thought of 🙂 And I think every new story is its own challenge – the learning is never done! 🙂

  8. tiltonph says:

    Susanna, I loved the pictures of the kids at th reading day. Looked like everyone had a lot of fun!

    Thanks for asking the question Erik. Agree with your response Susanna. It can be overwleming, especially if you have someone who is dominant. Think it's great exposure for you, but ultimately it is your MS and you will know what feels right or not. I like having a critique partner I trust. And, like Beth I have found the services of a professional freeland editor most helpful when I feel I've polished as much as I can.

  9. Leigh Covington says:

    I'm getting all emotional looking at the pictures of those kids with their books! I love it! How exciting and fun. I can't get enough of their smiling faces. :0)

    And your advice on crit work is good. I grew thick skin pretty quick, but sometimes things still get me down. It can be frustrating. I like the system you've mentioned. That is mostly what I do – and it makes a lot of sense. So glad you shared.

  10. Kirsten Larson says:

    Sorry, these kinds of posts bring tears to my eyes…kids going home with their very first books. I have so much admiration for all the kidlit authors I've met. Everyone is so giving. Thanks for supporting such a great organization.

  11. This Kid Reviews Bks says:

    It's so great that each kid got a book! I think most times people say things that really help but sometimes it may not come out right. Sometimes I get tired of “fixing” things but I see how it gets better. This was a great question and a great answer!

  12. Stacy S. Jensen says:

    Wonderful that the kids all got books! I LOVE the photo of the boy watching you sign the book. I'm enjoying the Oh Susanna questions and answers. Critique feedback is invaluable. I like your tips on how to tackle the feedback. I went through a critique training with a group and enjoyed this process, but the group didn't gel. Turns out one person in the group wasn't ready to be in a critique group — didn't follow basic format instructions and became defensive at feedback. Respecting your critique partner's time is key to making the group work.

  13. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    I know, Kirsten. I was so privileged to grow up in a home with books – it's hard to imagine that these kids have had none up until now. People were so wonderful to donate, and I hope all those kids are getting bedtime stories this week 🙂

  14. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    I know, Leigh. It was magical. They couldn't believe that they got to take brand new books home to keep.

    Glad you agree with the critique comments – it lends credence to them that a lot of people seem to feel the same way. Thanks!

  15. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    It really was great, Erik. You and I are lucky – we come from homes where reading is valued and we can afford books, or at least trips to the library. It's not something to be taken for granted – so many kid don't have that.

    I know how you feel about getting tired of fixing things! Wouldn't it be nice if we could write things perfectly the first time? 🙂

  16. Susanna Leonard Hill says:

    I love that you picked out that photo, Stacy. He was so fascinated. His head was right against mine so he could see everything I was doing 🙂 You make an excellent point about respecting critique partners' time – so true!

  17. HappyBirthdayAuthor says:

    Oh Susanna! Thanks for answering my question. Your response was very helpful. I like the idea of not deciding anything right away. I think I might take notes the next time to allow me to reflect upon the suggestions at a later time. Focusing on writing things down may keep my head from spinning!

  18. Iza Trapani says:

    What a satisfying day! Reach Out and Read is a great organization. Those kiddos sure look happy! Great question, Eric and Oh Susanna your answer is right on.

  19. Vicki Tremper says:

    Adorable photos! What a wonderful day that must have been. If 2 or more critiquers agree, I swallow pride and think about how I can implement their suggestion in a way that works for me. If just 1 makes a suggestion, I talk it out with myself to see if it makes sense to me or not.

  20. Dawnie23 says:

    *I love those pictures! Thanks for sharing and brightening my day!
    Being a part of a critique group is invaluable! It also can be confusing at times when you get conflicting advice on what doesn't work. I think ultimately you need to remember that it is YOUR story. Some writers who are new to the critique process mistakenly think they need to change everything that has been pointed out. Experience will teach you what needs fixing and what to leave alone. Above all, keep an open mind and be a gracious critiquer and/or critiquee.

  21. Clarike Bowman-Jahn says:

    Thanks for sharing all those lovely kiddo photos. They are truly precious. Thanks also for sharing the results of the clinic. congrats on a successful day.

    The tips on how to let the crit simmer are valid. Many times after waiting and letting the ms rest then you know what changes to make. good tips,Susanna.

  22. Peggy Eddleman says:

    Oh my goodness. FABULOUS advice! Yeah, I think we all just hope for the “This is the most brilliant thing ever!” comments, but that's what mothers are for. 😉 CPs, no matter how much info they give us, are the best.

  23. Janet Johnson says:

    What a fun event! And so awesome for the kids. I just love seeing kids with a new book.

    And great advice! I love the idea of categorizing the critiques out. Working on each one separately. MUCH more manageable that way!

  24. Renee LaTulippe says:

    Great advice, Susanna! I don't work with a critique group, but I do have a critique partner who gives fabulous, helpful feedback and even some tough love. I usually agree with her, and then just let it simmer for quite some time before trying to implement it. Do you ever get such good feedback that you're like “Could you just write the story for me?” Ha!

    The reading event looks so wonderful, and how cute are you there among all those sweeties! I love the pic of you signing the book — your little reader is intent on making sure you do it right! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s