Would You Read It Wednesday #115 – Tomboy Rules: Blossoms Are Always Prepared (MG) PLUS The November Pitch Pick

So, how’s everyone coming with their Holiday Contest entry?


Everybody working?

You’ll be completely unsurprised to discover that I have not even started my sample entry.

That is because I still have 5 full days.

OMG!  I only have 5 days!



Quick!  This calls for something calming!

Something Chocolate!!!

Oh, look!  We have Scotheroos, prepared by the lovely and talented Tina!

Scotcheroo courtesy of Tina Cho used with permission

According to Tina, the top is chocolate and butterscotch melted together… YUM…  The bottom is rice krispie, peanut butter and light corn syrup.  Doesn’t that sound delicious???  Please, help yourselves.  It’s important to maintain a steady caloric intake during cold weather to prevent frostbite 🙂

Ah.  I feel much calmer now.  Just let’s all take care not to remind me how I’m running out of time to write you-know-what for the you-know-what 🙂  And you guys have almost 5 more days than I do, so you’re all in good shape 🙂

Okay.  Time to get down to brass tacks.  First off, the November Pitch Pick.

Here are the 4 pitches, revised in response to your very helpful feedback (for which everyone was so grateful!)

#1 Steve
Rashad Saves The World (PB ages 5-8)
Rashad is tired of being the youngest and the least important member of his family. When he learns at school that he can save the world, he leaps straight into action and straight into trouble with his family as cell phones disappear down toilets and ice cream turns into soup. And when he accidentally demolishes the garden of his fearsome next door neighbour, his career as a Super Hero seems to have come to an abrupt end. Will he still be able to save the world? Perhaps he already has …

#2 Koren
Diary Of A Heroic Horse: Molly Gives Faith Hope (PB ages 6-13)

Two very special ponies are rescued in this heroic story of overcoming the odds to survive. Faith was stabled in Spain, where her former owners barely had a kind word for her, much less food. Molly was a casualty of Hurricane Katrina, the storm that devastated an entire American city.
Both left terribly injured, Faith and Molly were gifted back their freedom after becoming the first ponies in the world to be fitted with prosthetic legs, thanks to the determination of their rescuers.
Saving these two little horses brought together two families across the Atlantic to form a lasting friendship and a bond that can never be broken.
Share in the incredible story of Faith’s rescue and recovery, and her treasured friendship with Molly, in this diary-style picture book packed full of beautiful photographs.
All funds raised from the sale of this book are shared equally between the two charities that continue to care for Faith and Molly – Easy Horse Care Rescue Centre Foundation (in Spain) and Kids and Ponies – Molly’s Foundation (in America). Thank you for your support.

#3 Mary
Polka Dot Sue (PB ages 3-6)

Polka Dot Sue is the story of a young girl with polka dot hair, who takes great pride in who she is and conveys this pride with her enjoyment of clothing herself handsomely each day. The story gives a child the sense of self acceptance and pride to show others that a deep sense of self-empowerment come from believing in one self despite obstacles.  With  the color-emotion awareness, another sense of expressiveness, it encourages the young reader to understand more about feelings with color and self-expression.  Also with the encasement the days of the week the story gives the young reader an opportunity of for more fundamental growth.

#4 Lyla
The Good Morning Book (PB ages 0-4)
“Good morning world, now it’s day. Time for the sun to come out and play!” Jackson talks him mom into playing the Good Morning Game before brushing his teeth… “Good morning eyes, ears, nose and mouth. Good morning north, east, west and south.” Join these two on their morning adventure from Jackson’s bed as they visit all the animals, creatures in the sea, plants and trees, birds and bees… just to say… Good Morning.

Please choose the pitch you think is best and most deserves a read by editor Erin Molta and vote for it below by Sunday December 8 at 5 PM EST.

Many thanks!

Now then, today’s pitch comes to us from Beth who says, “I’m a former first grade teacher turned human development specialist (a.k.a full-time mom). In the early morning and during nap times, I work on humorous picture books and a middle grade novel (with series potential) about a tomboy. I also enjoy making up new words, blogging about the craft, and ending an occasional sentence, like any true Pittsburgher, with a preposition.”

Here is her pitch:

Working Title: Tomboy Rules: Blossoms Are Always Prepared
Age/Genre: Middle Grade (Realistic Fiction)
The Pitch: Mabel is so close to playing baseball she can almost see her spitting distance improving. Mom says all she has to do is stay in the Blossoms troop. But that isn’t easy. She turns a dosido into dominoes. She clobbers the troop leader saving a spider. Then she eats the entire cookie sale stash. Three strikes and she’s out, but that won’t stop Mabel. She sneaks to the Blossoms campsite and finds the Blossoms in a stinky situation only her tomboy talents can solve.

So what do you think?  Would You Read It?  YES, MAYBE or NO?

If your answer is YES, please feel free to tell us what you particularly liked and why the pitch piqued your interest.  If your answer is MAYBE or NO, please feel free to tell us what you think could be better in the spirit of helping Beth improve her pitch.  Helpful examples of possible alternate wordings are welcome.  (However, I must ask that comments be constructive and respectful.  I reserve the right not to publish comments that are mean because that is not what this is about.)
Please send YOUR pitches for the coming weeks!  For rules and where to submit, click on this link Would You Read It or on the Would You Read It tab in the bar above.  There are openings in February so you’ve got a little time to polish up your pitches and send yours for your chance to be read by editor Erin Molta!

Beth is looking forward to your thoughts on her pitch!  I am looking forward to being done with my dentist appointment, which I am probably suffering through right now whilst you are reading this post!  Whose idea was the dentist anyway?  Really, why would anyone what to BE a dentist?!  Ah well, I guess we can’t ALL be writers 🙂

Have a wonderful Wednesday everyone!  Happy writing 🙂

78 thoughts on “Would You Read It Wednesday #115 – Tomboy Rules: Blossoms Are Always Prepared (MG) PLUS The November Pitch Pick

  1. This_Kid_Reviews_Books_Erik says:

    I voted! I agree – 5 full days (what?!) is a GREAT time to finish a story! 🙂

    I would read the book. I just think the pitch is a little confusing. To me, a lot of it has nothing to do with baseball. Maybe have the beginning about her being a tomboy and knowing everything there is about [insert “boy” activity related with the ending]. I like books like this. My sister is a “Tom Boy” and it is good to have books like this! 🙂

  2. Tina Cho says:

    Boy was I surprised, Susanna, to see my Scotcheroo on your blog today! Hmm, I might need to make some more after seeing the photo.
    Yes, I'd read Beth's book. Sounds full of action. One thing I'm not understanding though is what playing baseball has to do with camping w/the Blossoms Troop. Otherwise, the rest of the pitch is full of interesting action.

  3. Andrea says:

    For me it's a maybe. I wondered why Mabel's mom is making her go in Blossoms if Mabel wants to play baseball. The line about dosido and dominoes sounded a little old-fashioned and a little confusing (I don't think of dominoes as tomboyish). But I love the idea of a tomboy character.

  4. Angela Brown says:

    That Scotcheroo looks so delicious!!

    I cast my vote, though it was a tough call.

    And yes I would read today's WYRI pitch. As the mom of a tomboy myself, I can see this being a story my daughter could really enjoy.

  5. pathaap says:

    Mmm, the chocolate, butterscotch & peanut butter – three of my favorites all in one!
    Yes, I would read today pitch because I like the idea of tomboy as the MC. But like the others, I was a bit confused. The first line made me think the story would be about baseball, not about her tomboy skills helping out the troop.

  6. Beth Arnstein says:

    Thanks for taking the time to read and comment on my pitch, Erik! Your suggestion for the beginning is a good one. And I'm glad you see use for a character like this. 🙂

  7. Beth Arnstein says:

    Tina, your recipe did sound delicious. Thanks for sharing! And thanks for posting about my pitch. Your comments will help me clean it up!

  8. Teresa Robeson says:

    Susanna, we know you always magically make a story entry appear when you need to! 😉

    Thanks to you and Tina for the yummy treats! 😀

    Voted! Good choices to pick from.

    And a Yes for the pitch. It sounds like a very cute idea. For me, I do need clarification on the condition: as long as she stays in the Blossoms for one more year? Forever? What exactly are Blossoms…girl scouts? Fun story though, Beth!

  9. Beth Arnstein says:

    Angela, I grew up a tomboy, also! I could never quite find a book with a character like me. Fingers crossed that I can get this pitch right so your daughter can read the book! Thanks!

  10. Beth Arnstein says:

    I agree on the dessert…er…breakfast. Sounds yummy! And thanks for commenting on my pitch. It looks like the consensus is that I need to change that first line. Thanks for your input!

  11. Wendi Silvano says:

    Yes… I would read it…sounds cute! But, I agree it's a little confusing. Maybe mention some more baseball related or “tomboy-like things” she does instead of eating the cookie stash, which is not exclusive to boys. I would focus more on the “sticky situation” she helps resolve (maybe a few more clues as to what that might be). Sounds like it might be a funny tale, so bring in a little more of the humor to the pitch if possible.

  12. Iza Trapani says:

    I love Beth's bio- human development specialist aka full time mom- And literally ending with a preposition- HAHA!

    I like the pitch as well (great opening line, though a few fixes are needed: I find this line a little confusing: “Mom says all she has to do is stay in the Blossoms troop.” The “all she has to do” suggests that after she does it, then she can go on to playing baseball. And I don't think that' what she means. I was trying to figure out what a dosido is and then realized that it needs hyphens: do-si-do.
    And I am confused as to why she sneaks to the Blossoms campsite. Isn't she already there?
    Otherwise, I love the humor and will love to read the story!

  13. Wendy Lawrence says:

    Okay, I love love love this, and the last line is phenomenal. Like some of the others, I was confused at the beginning though. I also tripped up over “dosido” and while I like the alliteration of the phrase with dominoes it took a few tries to figure out what you meant. I didn't know what a Blossoms troop was but I got it from context; maybe that's because I don't have girls. 🙂 And the title really threw me…I think a lot of this could be cleared up with a shorter title, one without a colon. The other thing that wasn't super clear was if the Blossoms troop or the baseball was the main story… but yes, this sounds awesome and with a little cleaning up of the pitch I think this will be great!

  14. Juliana Lee says:

    After all those yummy treats, I'm happy to have a dentist keep my smile bright! And as for Beth's proposal, I would read it despite the pitch's flaws because I love a good tomboy saves the Blossom Girls story. But I must say the pitch sounds a little juvenile for middle grade. I would try to spice it up with more of Mabel's voice and determination to play baseball. Play Ball!

  15. Cheryl Secomb says:

    Yes, I would read it. 🙂 I really like the pitch. It's concise and covers the key points. Great job, Beth. “Human development specialist” lol, I love it!

  16. Joanne Roberts says:

    Thanks for every thing, Susanna. Regarding the pitch, I would read it, with a caveat.
    I think the structure of the pitch is sound. I love the tone, clearly going to be a fun read. I can picture Mabel knocking down all the dancers (very funny). But I am a wee bit concerned about the whole “tomboy” thing.
    I think it's fantastic to write about a girl who likes baseball and doesn't fit in with the flowery camper organization, but I'd be sure to clarify to the editor I wasn't stereotyping the MC. My daughter was continually frustrated by books which portrayed sporty girls as awkward, crude, or unfeminine. She would've loved a book which depicted the girl characters as both sweet and active.
    Great job. Go for it!

  17. Beth Arnstein says:

    Iza, I'm glad you got the humor in my bio! Now if I can only get that humor to come across in the pitch as well! I'll work to clear up the confusing parts you mentioned. Thanks!

  18. Beth Arnstein says:

    I'm so glad you love it, Wendy! With a few tweaks, maybe you'll like it even more! Thanks for the suggestions! As for the title, I'm hoping the book becomes a series (called Tomboy Rules) and this is just the first book (called Blossoms are Always Prepared). Do you (Wendy or anyone else) have any advice on how to pitch it so the title isn't distracting?

  19. Beth Arnstein says:

    GREAT thinking point, Joanne. One of Mabel's problems in the story is that she is labeled a tomboy by her sister. Mabel really struggles with being labeled this way. I'm going to have to play around with the pitch and see if I can work that information into it. Thanks so much!

  20. Catherine Johnson says:

    The spitting distance part pulled me out of the story a bit even though it shows her tomboy character (but if no one else mentions it ;)) The rest I love!

  21. Linda Boyden says:

    A definite YES! Like many have said, I love Mabel's voice. I survived last year having to take a 6 yo to Daisies (a young division of Girl Scouts) and so the pitch made a lot of sense to me. The cookie sales! The “stealing”of said cookies when leaders weren't looking!! Maybe refine the word tomboy. Mabel just isn't a girly girl and that's fine. Best of luck with this one!

    And Susanna, you're correct, chocolate is the cure of many woes. 🙂

  22. Pam Brunskill says:

    I love the pitch. Yes, I would read it. It's clear that there's a humorous voice, action, and a sweet solution. I was a little confused when you mentioned tomboy at the end. Perhaps you could just say that it's a situation only Mabel can solve? That said, I think it's strong enough to get an agent or editor to turn the page. Good luck with this!

  23. Steve Moran says:

    Yep, I'd read it. I do think though that all your short sentences, one after the other, don't let me get involved as much as I'd like to. Perhaps joining 2 or 3 of them together into something like … 'after turning a dosido into dominoes, clobbering her troup leader in a spider-saving moment and managing to eat the entire … ' might give you a little more variation and flow?

  24. Stacy Couch says:

    Oh, dentists! Melissa Guion had a hil-LAR-ious PiBoIdMo post about dentists, genius and Percy Shelley. Probably not a PB-friendly experience, though.

    Beth, I love the humor in Mabel's antics. And the potentially “stinky” climax. The source of the confusion, though, seems to be the stakes. What is the main conflict of the novel? Does Mabel have to stay in the Blossoms to play baseball?
    Whatever the main conflict is, I'd state it (with Mabel-esque attitude), use the antics to support conflict, and hint at what the stinky climax might be.

  25. Beth Arnstein says:

    Thanks, Catherine. I think some others had trouble with the spitting distance not being anchored to anything else. Noted! 🙂

  26. Beth Arnstein says:

    Linda, I survived a short bout in Daisies myself. Barely. Just kidding, but I probably did draw on that a little for the story. Thanks for the word choice advice!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s